1993
Rings
by Aden Ross
62 Homers
by Red Shuttleworth
The Brother’s Silence
by Jerry L. Crawford
One Family
by Jim Leonard Jr.
1994
Rainy Days and Friday Nights
by Sam Smiley
Portrait of a Nude
by Laura Shamas
The Incompetents
by T. C. Miller
The Color of Bruise
by Nicole Thomas
1995
Heir to the Covenant
by Robert Paxton
Tenderhooks
by Julie Jensen
A Woman of Power
by Edward F. Emanuel
Glass Mountain
by Doris Baizley
1996
Ballad Hunter
by Jenny Laird
Sacrament of Meatballs
by Mark Steven Jensen
Gadianton
by Eric Samuelson
Sacrilege
by Edward Mast
1997
Who Loves You, Jimmie Orio
by Cheryldee Huddleston
Our Lady Guenevere
by Ace Pilkington
The Spirit Seekers
by William Lang
What in the World’s Come Over You?
by Red Shuttleworth
1998
A Grief of Mind
by Carl O’Neal Rich
Simply the Thing She Is
by Kate Hawley
March Tale
by Tim Slover
Sweet Maggie Blues
by Kay K. Cook
1999
Autumn in the Valley
by John D. and James A. Bell
The Lamentable Tragedy of Sir Thomas More
by Ann Chamberlain
E. Pluribus Anarchy
by Paavo Hall
Dispute Bones
by Jonathan Graham
2000
Whistler vs. Ruskin
by L.L. West
Memorabilia
by Red Shutterworth
The Tears of Time
by Stuart Boyce
Little Red Wagon Painted Blue
by Ron Monaco
2001
Tucumcari
by Riley Steiner
The Figurehead
by Charise Menefee
Next Rest Stop 78 Miles
by Marianne Hales
2002
The Stardust Caper
by Jerry L. Crawford
Trucker Rhapsody
by Toni Press-Coffman
Misdirected
by Joe Borini
Across the Line
by David Barr III
2003
Digging in the Margins
by Mark Rigney
Summer Feet
by Riley Steiner
The Queen’s Two Bodies
by Jeanne Murray-Walker
Independency
by Mark Steven Jensen
2004
Lady Macbeth
by Aden Ross
Gaining Ground
by Mark Rigney
Tears in the Sand
by Stuart Boyce
2005
The Hard Way
by Gino de Iorio
Downwinders
by Ed Kociela
Speak to Me, Annie
by Kay K. Cook
2006
Nemo 1934 (now The End of the Horizon)
by Debora Threedy
Opaline
by Mary Fengar-Gail
The Moor Lark
by Jan Henson-Dow
2007
Breaking the Shakespeare Code
by John Minigan
Early Poe
by Dan Trujillo
The Thousand Pound Marriage
by Richard Kalinowski
2008
Di Esperienza
by Matthew Ivan Bennett
Father Mike
by TJ Edwards
Germinous Seeds
by David Rush
2009
Big Dance
by Jim Lord
Nell Gwyn
by Fred C. Adams
2010
Behold
by Tom Cavanaugh
The Zapruder Film
by Todd Goodlett
Making Waves
by Amanda Waterhouse
2011
Lying to Spielberg
by Bill Nabel
The Galt Regency
by Judith Montague
King of the Cats
by Glenn Barrett
2012
The Greater Love
by Frankie Little Hardin
Turquoise Wind
by Kurt Proctor
Play Desdemona
by Daniel Hintzsche